Getting your emails opened is half the battle. You can spend hours crafting the perfect message, but if the subject line falls flat, it might never even be seen. In the crowded world of email marketing—especially in eCommerce—your subject line is your first and often only chance to grab attention.
Think of it as your headline. It needs to spark curiosity, promise value, and stand out in a cluttered inbox—all in under ten words. That might sound like a big ask, but with a little strategy and a lot of testing, it’s entirely achievable.
Table of Contents
Why Subject Lines Matter More Than You Think
Customers are overwhelmed with emails every day—from brands they follow, ones they’ve forgotten about, and plenty they never signed up for. Whether they decide to open or ignore your message is usually determined in just a second or two.
The subject line is the trigger. If it’s engaging, relevant, or intriguing, it buys you a few more seconds of attention. If it’s generic or unclear, it may get overlooked—or worse, sent straight to the bin. That’s why writing effective subject lines isn’t just copywriting—it’s a core part of your email strategy.
And while it’s tempting to rely on a set formula, what works well for one audience or brand might flop for another. The best subject lines are informed by a deep understanding of your customer, a clear purpose behind the email, and a willingness to experiment.
Finding the Right Balance
Writing subject lines isn’t just about being clever—it’s about being clear. The best-performing ones often combine clarity with a hint of intrigue. Your readers should know what they’ll get if they open the email, but still feel curious enough to want to find out more.
Tone plays a big role here. If your brand is known for being playful, a touch of humour or personality can make your emails stand out. If you’re more premium or formal, a subject line that focuses on quality, exclusivity or simplicity might work better.
It’s also worth remembering that people respond emotionally. Words like “exclusive,” “limited,” “just for you,” or “ends soon” often perform well because they tap into urgency or personal relevance. But overuse of these tactics can backfire. If every email screams for attention, none of them stand out.
Avoiding the Pitfalls
Some subject lines fail not because they’re boring, but because they feel insincere or misleading. If your subject promises something that your email doesn’t deliver, you risk damaging trust—and no short-term open rate boost is worth that.
Equally, trying too hard to be different can confuse rather than attract. Clarity should always win over cleverness if you’re forced to choose. You want readers to understand the benefit of opening your email without having to guess what it’s about.
Personalisation can help, but it needs to be used with care. Including someone’s name or referencing a past purchase can increase engagement—but only if it feels authentic and useful, not forced or creepy.
The Role of A/B Testing
Even the most experienced marketers can’t always predict which subject line will perform best. That’s why testing is essential. A simple A/B test—sending two variations to a small portion of your list—can reveal surprising insights into what your audience responds to.
Sometimes a subject line that feels too simple can outperform a creative one. Other times, small changes in word order or punctuation can make a big difference. Over time, these tests build up a valuable knowledge base about your audience’s preferences, helping you refine your approach.
If you’re unsure how to implement testing effectively, working with a trusted Email Marketing Agency can give you the structure and insight to get better results, faster.
Optimising for Mobile and Preview Text
With more than half of emails now opened on mobile devices, your subject line needs to be effective even when space is limited. Aim for brevity, but don’t sacrifice meaning. Keep your most important words at the start, so they don’t get cut off.
Don’t forget the preview text—the line that appears next to or beneath your subject. This is an extension of your message and can increase opens if used wisely. Rather than repeating the subject, use it to provide a teaser or extra detail that supports the main hook.
Together, the subject line and preview text should work as a team: one draws people in, the other convinces them to click.
Final Thoughts
Your subject line may only be a few words long, but it carries the weight of your entire email campaign. It’s your handshake, your headline, your invitation. Getting it right can mean the difference between a successful email and one that disappears without a trace.
To master the art of the subject line, you need a mix of creativity, customer understanding, and data-driven testing. It’s not about tricks—it’s about clarity, timing, and value. Keep improving, keep testing, and stay aligned with what your customers actually care about.
Because if they’re not opening your emails, they’re not seeing your offers—and that’s a missed opportunity no eCommerce brand can afford.
